Making markets
FX market making
The foreign exchange market is the largest in the world and has no central exchange. Dealers – big banks and a few non-bank firms – stream buy and sell prices to clients and platforms around the clock, match clients who buy against clients who sell inside their own books, and hedge only what is left. The edge is in pricing, in the flow a dealer sees, and in netting it well.
At a glance
At a glance
- Makes money from
- The spread on client trades, kept by netting buyers against sellers before hedging what is left
- Holds positions for
- Seconds to hours; risk passes between offices in Asia, London and New York
- Trades
- Spot, forwards, swaps and non-deliverable forwards in major and emerging currencies
- Biggest risk
- Gaps when a central bank surprises the market, and being picked off by faster clients
- Who does it
- Bank dealers such as JPMorgan, UBS and Deutsche Bank, and non-banks such as XTX Markets and Jump Trading
- $9.6tn – traded on an average day (BIS survey, April 2025)
- 42% – of it in FX swaps (spot 31%, forwards 19%)
- ~9 in 10 – trades with the dollar on one side (BIS survey)
- 80%+ – of spot flow netted internally by the largest dealers (BIS, 2019)
- 5 min – window of the 4pm London fix (widened from 1 minute in 2015)
- £1.1bn – FCA fines on five banks over the fix (November 2014)
The business
Currencies trade over the counter: there is no single exchange and no single price. A pension fund buying dollars, a car maker hedging next year’s euro revenue and a retail broker’s customers all trade with dealers, who stream prices to them over electronic platforms and through their own apps. Nearly nine trades in ten have the dollar on one side, and London handles more than any other centre.
A dealer that sees a lot of flow can often match a client buying euros against another selling them a few seconds later, and keep the whole spread without touching the market. This is internalisation, and it is why scale matters so much: the largest dealers net most of their spot flow internally, and hedge only the remainder on the interdealer venues – EBS and LSEG FX Matching – or with other dealers.
Where a dealer’s flow goes
What trades in a day
A trade, step by step
Electronic FX dealers quote in pips: the fourth decimal place for most pairs, so 0.0001 in EUR/USD, and the second for yen pairs. In the busiest pairs, spreads to large clients are a fraction of a pip.
Worked example
A minute on the EUR/USD book
The market mid is 1.10000. The dealer bids 1.09995 and offers 1.10005 – half a pip either side – and starts the minute flat.
- A fund sells €5m paid out−$5,499,750
- A company buys €3m received+$3,300,150
- Position leftlong €2m
- The mid falls a pip; hedge on EBS received+$2,199,780
- Net, flat in euros+$180
The €3m netted between the two clients earned the full pip: $300. The €2m that had to be hedged lost $120, because the price fell before the dealer could sell – the seller of €5m was a better guide to the next move than the buyer of €3m. Internalising more of the flow, and skewing prices to attract the other side, is the whole craft.
Rather than hedging at once, a dealer long euros usually skews: it lowers both its bid and its offer slightly, so its offer becomes the best in the market and euro buyers come to it, while its bid is less attractive to further sellers. Waiting to be hit is cheaper than crossing the spread – as long as the price does not run away first.
Skewing prices to the position
The maths that matters
Covered interest parity. A forward rate is not a forecast: it is set by the two interest rates, because borrowing one currency, converting it and investing in the other must cost the same as agreeing the exchange now for later. For EUR/USD, quoted in dollars per euro, . The currency with the lower interest rate trades at a premium in the forward market.
Worked example
A one-year EUR/USD forward
Spot is 1.1000. Illustrative one-year rates: 4% on dollars, 2% on euros, simple interest.
- Forward1.12157
- Forward points+215.7 pips
The euro is more expensive for delivery in a year because it earns 2% less interest in the meantime. Dealers quote forwards as these points added to spot, and an FX swap desk is in effect trading the difference between two interest rates.
Since 2008 parity has not held exactly: borrowing dollars through an FX swap has usually cost more than the dollar interest rate, a gap called the cross-currency basis. Du, Tepper and Verdelhan (2018) traced it to the cost of bank balance sheets, which limits how much arbitrage banks will do – the same constraint that matters in fixed-income relative value.
Triangular consistency. With three currencies, any one cross rate is implied by the other two. A dealer’s engine prices every cross from the most liquid pairs, and checks constantly that it is not offering an arbitrage.
Worked example
Is EUR/JPY consistent?
EUR/USD 1.1000, USD/JPY 150.00 and EUR/JPY 165.20, all mids, and no spreads – to see the arithmetic.
- Implied EUR/JPY165.00
- How rich is the quote?+0.12%
- Sell €1m for yen+¥165,200,000
- Buy back €1m with dollars−$1,100,000
- Buy those dollars with yen−¥165,000,000
- Profit≈ $1,333
A gap this size never lasts: with the spreads on three legs to pay, a real mispricing is a fraction of a pip and survives milliseconds. Its main use in an interview is to see if you can keep the conventions straight.
Where the money comes from
The minute on the EUR/USD book, taken apart
- Spot and forwards to clients: a small spread on enormous volume, kept mainly by netting.
- Swaps and forwards: the bank’s balance sheet and funding are the product, priced off the interest-rate differential and the basis.
- Emerging-market currencies: wider spreads, thinner markets and capital controls, traded through non-deliverable forwards settled in dollars.
- Options: a separate volatility desk, with the same economics as options market making.
- Prime brokerage: banks lend their credit to hedge funds and non-bank dealers so they can trade with everyone else in the bank’s name – a fee business, and a credit risk.
Non-bank firms have taken a large share of the spot business since about 2015 by being faster and cheaper to run, while banks keep the clients that need credit, forwards, swaps and settlement. Last look – a window of a few milliseconds in which a dealer may reject a trade a client has accepted at its price – protects dealers from being picked off by faster clients. The FX Global Code, updated in December 2024, says it must be used only to check the trade and the price, never to profit from information in the client’s request.
Risk and what goes wrong
The market is very deep most of the time and very thin at a few moments: when a central bank acts by surprise, when the Asian session is quiet, and around holidays. Stop-loss orders do not protect anyone if the price jumps past them. The dealer also holds the credit risk of its clients until they pay.
Herstatt · June 1974
German regulators closed Bankhaus Herstatt after it had received Deutsche marks from its counterparties but before it had paid out the dollars it owed them in New York. Settlement risk between time zones is still called Herstatt risk; the CLS settlement system, launched in 2002, exists to remove it.
The fix scandal · November 2014
The FCA fined five banks £1.1 billion for traders sharing client orders in chat rooms to move the 4pm London fix. In May 2015 US and UK authorities announced further penalties of about $5.6 billion on five banks. The fix window was widened from one minute to five.
The Swiss franc floor goes · 15 January 2015
The Swiss National Bank abandoned without warning its floor of 1.20 francs per euro. EUR/CHF fell below 0.90 within minutes, with almost no prices in between. Retail broker FXCM was left owing $225 million by clients whose losses exceeded their deposits.
Sterling’s flash crash · 7 October 2016
The pound fell several per cent against the dollar within minutes in thin Asian trading, and recovered most of it. A Bank for International Settlements study found no single cause: thin liquidity, automated selling and options hedging fed each other.
The yen carry unwind · 5 August 2024
After a Bank of Japan rate rise, investors who had borrowed cheaply in yen to buy higher-yielding assets rushed to buy yen back. USD/JPY fell from above 160 in early July to about 142, and Japan’s stock market had its worst day since 1987.
Technology and data
- A pricing engine that combines prices from twenty or more venues into a fair mid for every pair, many times a second, and turns it into a separate stream for each client, by size and by how that client has traded before.
- Client analytics: markouts on every client’s trades, so flow that is consistently informed gets wider prices or a different stream.
- Smart hedging: when to hedge, where and in what size, to avoid signalling the position to the market.
- Credit and settlement: limits for every client checked before each trade, and settlement through CLS.
- Around the clock: the book is handed from Asia to London to New York, from Sunday evening to Friday evening New York time.
The trading day
| Time (London) | What happens |
|---|---|
| 22:00 Sunday | The week opens as Monday begins in Wellington and Sydney |
| 01:55 | The Tokyo fix (9:55 in Tokyo), used by Japanese companies and banks |
| 07:00–08:00 | London opens: the busiest stretch of the day begins |
| 13:15 | The ECB’s euro reference rates (14:15 in Frankfurt) |
| 13:00–16:00 | London and New York overlap: the deepest market of the day |
| 15:57:30–16:02:30 | The WM/Reuters fix: the benchmark for funds and indices |
| 22:00 Friday | New York closes (17:00 there) and the week ends |
Who works here
Electronic trader or quant trader
Runs the algorithms that price and hedge a set of currency pairs: sets spreads and skews, watches markouts by client and venue, and steps in when markets become disorderly, such as around central-bank decisions.
Quant or strat
Builds the fair-value, skew and hedging models, analyses client flow to tier pricing, and tests changes against recorded data.
Developer
Builds the pricing and hedging engine and its connections to dozens of venues and platforms, where milliseconds matter and an outage means quoting stale prices to every client at once.
Sales-trader
Handles large or unusual client trades by voice and chat, such as a company hedging an acquisition, where the size needs pricing by hand.
In interviews for this desk
Expect mental arithmetic with currency conventions – pips, crosses, forwards – and market-making games. Electronic FX desks also ask about skewing, hedging and how to tell informed flow from uninformed; graduate roles test probability and coding.
EUR/USD is 1.1000, one-year dollar rates are 4% and euro rates 2%. Where is the one-year forward?
, or 215.7 pips above spot. The lower-yielding currency, the euro, is at a forward premium – otherwise you could borrow euros, convert, invest in dollars and sell the dollars forward for a free profit.
What is one pip worth on $10 million of USD/JPY at 150?
A yen pip is 0.01, so , which is about $667 at 150.
EUR/USD is 1.1000, USD/JPY 150.00 and EUR/JPY 165.20. Is there an arbitrage, and how would you trade it?
The implied cross is , so EUR/JPY is 0.12% rich. Sell euros for yen at 165.20, buy the euros back with dollars at 1.1000, and buy those dollars with yen at 150.00: about ¥200,000 on each €1m – before spreads, which in practice close anything this large instantly.
You are long €50 million and a client asks for a two-way price in €20 million. How do you quote?
Skew down: a lower offer to encourage the client to buy, and a bid further below mid because buying another €20m would make the position worse. Widen for the size and for what you know of the client. Do not show the client your position by skewing so much that the price is obviously one-sided.
What is last look, and why do clients dislike it?
A short window after a client accepts a price in which the dealer may still reject the trade. It protects dealers from clients who trade on prices that are already stale, so they can quote tighter. Clients dislike the uncertainty and the chance that the dealer rejects only trades that would lose it money; the FX Global Code forbids using the window to trade on the client’s information.
Why does a big dealer have an advantage in spot FX?
The more flow it sees, the more of it nets internally: a buyer and a seller a few seconds apart both pay the spread, and neither needs hedging in the market. A small dealer has to hedge most trades and pays the spread itself. Scale also gives better information on where the price is going.
The Swiss central bank had held EUR/CHF above 1.20 for three years. What should a market maker have learned from 15 January 2015?
A rate held by policy is not a rate held by the market: the risk is a jump, not a drift, and stop-losses and models built on daily volatility say nothing about it. Size positions and client credit for the jump, and price options on such pairs with heavy tails.
Firm guides: Jump Trading · Citadel Securities
Glossary
- Pip
- The standard price increment: 0.0001 for most pairs, 0.01 for yen pairs.
- Spot
- An exchange of currencies for settlement in two business days, usually.
- Forward points
- The difference between the forward and spot rates, set by the interest rates.
- FX swap
- A spot trade and an opposite forward trade together – a way to borrow one currency against another.
- Non-deliverable forward
- A forward on a restricted currency, settled by paying the difference in dollars rather than exchanging the currencies.
- Internalisation
- Netting one client’s trade against another’s inside the dealer’s own book.
- Skew
- Shading both prices one way to attract the trade that reduces the position.
- Last look
- A short window in which a dealer may reject a trade at its quoted price.
- The fix
- A benchmark rate set from trading in a short window, such as the WM/Reuters 4pm London rate.
- Covered interest parity
- The rule that sets forwards from spot and the two currencies’ interest rates.
- Cross-currency basis
- The extra cost of borrowing a currency through an FX swap, beyond parity.
- Prime brokerage
- A bank lending its name and credit so a client can trade with other dealers.
Further reading
- Triennial Central Bank Survey of Foreign Exchange and OTC Derivatives Markets – Bank for International Settlements, 2025
- FX Global Code – Global Foreign Exchange Committee, 2024
- FX trade execution: complex and highly fragmented – Andreas Schrimpf and Vladyslav Sushko, 2019
- The sterling “flash event” of 7 October 2016 – BIS Markets Committee, 2017
- Deviations from Covered Interest Rate Parity – Wenxin Du, Alexander Tepper and Adrien Verdelhan, 2018. Journal of Finance