Making markets
Options market making
An options market maker quotes prices on calls and puts across every strike and expiry, a little either side of a theoretical value from its model. It hedges the direction straight away with the underlying and manages what is left – exposure to big moves and to volatility itself – across the whole book.
At a glance
At a glance
- Makes money from
- Edge against theoretical value on each trade, kept by hedging away the direction
- Holds positions for
- The hedge is immediate; the options book runs from hours to weeks, often to expiry
- Trades
- Listed options on shares, indices, ETFs and futures, hedged with the underlying
- Biggest risk
- Large moves when short gamma, and changes in implied volatility (vega)
- Who does it
- Options specialists such as SIG, Optiver, IMC, Citadel Securities and Akuna Capital
- 20 – US options exchanges (as of October 2026)
- 15.2bn – US options contracts cleared (2025, OCC, up 24%)
- 61m – contracts a day on average (2025, Cboe)
- 59% – of S&P 500 index options traded on their expiry day (2025, Cboe)
- $0.30–1.20 – paid per contract for retail orders (one broker’s 2024 tiers)
- 1% – daily move at 16% volatility (the rule of 16)
The business
Customers come to the options market to hedge a portfolio, to lever a view, or to sell volatility for income. They want a price in whatever strike and expiry suits them, and there are thousands. The market maker supplies all of them from one model: a volatility surface fitted to the market, from which every option has a theoretical value. It sells a little above that value, buys a little below, and hedges what it takes on.
US listed options trade on 20 exchanges, as of October 2026, all cleared through one central counterparty, the Options Clearing Corporation. Exchanges appoint market makers with obligations and privileges: on Cboe, a market maker must quote 60% of the series in its classes for 90% of the time, and a lead or designated market maker at the best price is guaranteed a share of incoming orders – up to half when only one other firm is there with it.
Retail volume has transformed the business. OCC cleared 15.2 billion contracts in 2025, up 24% on the year, and 59% of S&P 500 index option volume that year was in options expiring the same day. Brokers sell their retail option orders to wholesalers – one broker’s 2024 disclosures show $0.30 to $1.20 a contract – and an academic study found three firms paying nearly 90% of that payment for order flow.
One customer trade, and the hedging behind it
Who is on the other side, and why
| Who | Typically | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Institutions hedging | Buy index puts | Protect a portfolio against a fall |
| Overwriters | Sell calls on what they own | Income from premium |
| Retail traders | Buy short-dated calls and puts | Leverage on a view |
| Volatility funds | Sell or buy volatility | The gap between implied and realised |
| Structured-product desks | Hedge what they sold to clients | Offset the options inside their notes |
A trade, step by step
Every options trade has two parts: the edge captured when it is done, and everything that happens to the hedge afterwards. A good desk makes most of its money from the first and keeps the second small.
Worked example
Selling 100 calls and living with the hedge for a day
A one-month call struck at 100, with the stock at 100 and implied volatility 20%. Each contract covers 100 shares, so 100 contracts are 10,000 options. No interest or dividends, to keep the arithmetic clean.
- Theoretical valueBlack–Scholes at 20% volatility, 30 days2.29
- A customer buys 100 calls at 2.34 options of edge+$500
- Hedge the deltaDelta 0.51, so buy 5,100 shares
- A day passes: time decayShort options earn theta: +$381
- The stock rises 1.50Gamma 0.0695: −$782
- Re-hedgeDelta is now 0.615: buy about 1,040 more sharesflat again
Net +$99: the edge paid for a day in which the stock moved more than the options were priced for. Twenty per cent a year is about a 1.05 move a day; the stock moved 1.50, so the short gamma lost more than theta earned. Had it moved less than 1.05, the day would have made money on top of the edge.
- Fit the surface: implied volatility by strike and expiry, refitted as the market moves, so every option has a theoretical value.
- Quote theoretical value plus or minus an edge, wider for size, for illiquid strikes and when the book is already long or short the risk.
- Hedge delta at once with the stock, an ETF or a future.
- Manage what remains across the whole book: gamma by expiry, vega by expiry, skew, and the risk of an early exercise or a stock pinned at a strike on expiry day.
The maths that matters
Delta is how much the option moves for a one-point move in the stock; gamma is how fast delta changes. Near expiry gamma concentrates at the strike, so an at-the-money option’s delta can swing from near 0 to near 1 in a small move – the risk a market maker short gamma carries into expiry.
Delta against the price, for three expiries
For a delta-hedged option the day’s profit, before edge and costs, is approximately . The holder of an option wins when the market moves more than its price assumed; the seller wins when it moves less. With no rates, theta and gamma are tied together: , which is why a long-gamma position always pays time decay for its convexity.
Two rules of thumb do most of the mental arithmetic. A volatility of 16% is about 1% a day, because . And an at-the-money straddle costs about – one month at 20% volatility on a 100 stock is about 4.6.
The volatility smile: index options
A sold call, hedged with half a share
Where the money comes from
A day’s P&L on an options book, explained
Vega is the term that can swamp the others. A book that has sold more options than it bought is short volatility, and loses when implied volatility rises – which it does in exactly the sell-offs when hedging is hardest. Desks measure vega by expiry, and often weight short-dated vega more, because front-month implied volatility moves more than long-dated.
Risk and what goes wrong
The famous volatility blow-ups were mostly funds that had sold volatility, not market makers – the market maker’s hedging is what keeps it alive. But a wrong surface, an unhedged gap or a technical fault can still hurt badly.
The crash that made the smile · 19 October 1987
The Dow fell 22.6% in a day. Before it, index implied volatility was roughly flat across strikes; ever since, puts have traded at a premium. Options market makers and their clearing firms took heavy losses, and the largest options clearing firm needed its parent bank’s support.
An options order error · 20 August 2013
A configuration fault at a large bank sent about 16,000 mispriced options orders at the open, around 1.5 million contracts traded within minutes, and many were later cancelled. The SEC fined the bank $7 million in 2015 under its rule on market access controls.
“Volmageddon” · 5 February 2018
The VIX rose from 17.31 to 37.32, its largest one-day percentage rise. A popular exchange-traded note that was short volatility lost about 96% and was closed; a fund that sold S&P options lost about 80% in two days and was liquidated.
The VIX’s record close · 16 March 2020
The VIX closed at 82.69. A variance-swap fund with about $600 million wound down, and a large manager’s options-selling funds lost up to 97%; the firm later pleaded guilty to securities fraud.
A spike before the open · 5 August 2024
The VIX printed 65.73 before the US cash open and closed near 40. Studies by the BIS and SEC staff found thin liquidity had widened option quotes, lifting the index more than the market itself moved.
Technology and data
- Pricing engines that revalue tens of thousands of series on every move in the underlying – Black–Scholes or Black-76 for European options, trees or finite differences for American ones with dividends and early exercise.
- Surface fitting with arbitrage-free parameterisations such as SVI, so no combination of quoted options can be traded for a free profit.
- Risk aggregated by underlying and expiry, with scenario grids that move spot and volatility together, and exchange “market-maker protection” that pulls quotes after a burst of fills.
- Pre-trade controls on every order – the lesson of the 2013 error.
Who works here
Options trader
Re-marks the surface before the open around earnings and events, then watches fills and Greeks, adjusts skew and term structure, hedges vega with other options and handles large or complex orders. After the close, attributes the day’s P&L to edge, gamma, vega and theta.
Volatility researcher
Forecasts realised volatility and event moves, models skew and term structure, measures which fills are adverse, and backtests quoting parameters.
Developer
Builds the pricing and Greeks library, surface calibration, exchange gateways, the risk and limits engine, and the simulation that tests changes before they go live.
In interviews for this desk
Options desks ask about put–call parity, the Greeks and delta hedging, often in a market-making game where the rules change. Mental arithmetic and probability under time pressure come first.
The stock is 100, a one-year 100-strike call is 10 and the put is 5, with rates at 5%. Is there an arbitrage?
Parity says , but the market has 5, so the call is rich. Sell the call, buy the put and the stock, borrow 95.12: you collect today and owe nothing at expiry in any state.
Why is an at-the-money call’s delta a little above 0.5?
Delta is with at the money, which is positive. At 20% volatility, one year and no rates, delta is . The probability of finishing in the money is , a little below 0.5.
You are long an option with gamma 0.05 on a 100 stock at 16% volatility. The stock moves 2 today. Roughly what do you make?
Theta is a year, about −0.025 a day here, since 16% is 1% a day. The move earns . Net about ; the break-even move is one daily standard deviation, 1.
Roughly what does a one-month at-the-money straddle cost on a 100 stock at 20% volatility?
About (Black–Scholes gives 4.61). The break-evens at expiry are about 95.4 and 104.6 – the straddle price is roughly the expected absolute move.
How would you price a digital call that pays 1 if the stock finishes above 100?
It is the limit of a tight call spread, . With flat volatility it is – 0.46 at the money, 20% volatility, one year. With negative skew, add the call’s vega times the skew slope, which makes the digital dearer than the flat-volatility price.
Make a market in an option that pays the roll of a die minus 4, if positive.
It pays 1 on a 5 and 2 on a 6, so it is worth ; quote around 0.40 / 0.60. The matching put, paying 4 minus the roll, is worth 1.00, and parity checks out: .
Which has more vega, a one-month or a one-year at-the-money option?
The one-year: at the money vega is about , so roughly times as much. Gamma goes the other way. But front-month volatility moves more, so desks compare weighted vega – short-dated books carry gamma risk, long-dated ones vega risk.
Firm guides: SIG (Susquehanna) · Optiver · IMC Trading · Citadel Securities · Akuna Capital
Glossary
- Implied volatility
- The volatility that makes a model’s price equal the market price.
- Volatility surface
- Implied volatility by strike and expiry.
- Skew
- How implied volatility varies across strikes; for indices, puts are dearer.
- Term structure
- How implied volatility varies across expiries.
- Delta
- How much the option moves for a one-point move in the underlying.
- Gamma
- How fast delta changes as the underlying moves.
- Vega
- How much the option moves for a one-point change in implied volatility.
- Theta
- The option’s loss of value with one day’s passing.
- Put–call parity
- Call minus put equals the stock minus the discounted strike, for European options.
- Pin risk
- Uncertainty over exercise when the stock sits at a strike on expiry.
- Lead market maker
- An exchange-appointed quoter with obligations and a guaranteed share of orders.
- 0DTE
- Options traded on the day they expire.
Further reading
- Option Volatility and Pricing – Sheldon Natenberg, 2014. The trader’s book on options – the one most desks hand to new joiners
- Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives – John C. Hull, 2021
- Volatility Trading – Euan Sinclair, 2013. Second edition, Wiley
- Arbitrage-free SVI volatility surfaces – Jim Gatheral and Antoine Jacquier, 2014
- Retail Trading in Options and the Rise of the Big Three Wholesalers – Svetlana Bryzgalova, Anna Pavlova and Taisiya Sikorskaya, 2023