Making markets
ETF market making
An exchange-traded fund holds a basket – the shares in an index, a set of bonds – and trades on an exchange like a single stock. Market makers quote the ETF tightly and hedge with the basket, futures or similar funds. When the ETF’s price drifts from the value of its holdings, the largest of them can create or redeem fund shares with the issuer, which is the arbitrage that pulls the two back together.
At a glance
At a glance
- Makes money from
- The spread on ETF trades, and the gap between ETF price and basket value
- Holds positions for
- Minutes to days; inventory is netted, hedged or turned into creations and redemptions
- Trades
- ETFs, the shares or bonds they hold, index futures and related funds
- Biggest risk
- Hedge mismatch – the basket may be closed, illiquid or stale when the ETF trades
- Who does it
- Firms such as Jane Street, Flow Traders, Optiver and Citadel Securities, alongside bank dealers
- $19.85tn – in ETFs worldwide (end-2025, ETFGI)
- $13.4tn – in US ETFs, 4,495 funds (end-2025, ICI)
- 88% – of ETF activity is trading on exchange, not creations (2025, ICI)
- 28% – of US stock-market volume is ETFs (2025 average, ICI)
- 50,000 – shares in a typical creation unit (ICI)
- 5.0% – a large bond ETF’s discount to NAV (12 March 2020)
The business
Most ETF trading never touches the fund. In 2025, 88% of US ETF activity was investors buying and selling shares from each other on exchanges, with market makers in the middle; only 12% was the creation and redemption of new shares. That ratio is what makes ETFs cheap to trade: a buyer meets a market maker’s quote, and the market maker decides later – or never – whether to touch the underlying basket.
Two roles matter. Authorised participants are dealers with an agreement with the fund issuer; only they can create or redeem shares, and they have no obligation to. In 2024 each US ETF had on average 18 of them registered and 4 active. Lead market makers are appointed by the exchange to quote a particular ETF continuously. One firm is often both, but neither role requires the other.
The SEC’s 2019 “ETF rule” made the business uniform in the US: funds publish their full holdings every day before the open, along with yesterday’s premium or discount to net asset value and their median bid–ask spread, and may agree custom baskets with authorised participants. Exchanges dropped the old requirement to publish an indicative value every 15 seconds – it was too stale for anyone to trade on.
Creation and redemption
If the ETF trades above the value of its holdings, an authorised participant buys the basket, delivers it to the issuer in exchange for new ETF shares – a creation unit, typically 50,000 shares – and sells those shares on the exchange. If the ETF trades below, it does the reverse: buys ETF shares cheaply and redeems them for the basket. Creations and redemptions are usually charged a flat fee per order – $500 at some large issuers – and can be in shares (in kind) or in cash.
A creation: closing a premium
Worked example
A redemption that closes a discount
An ETF trades at $99.85 while its basket is worth $100.00 a share – a 0.15% discount. The creation unit is 50,000 shares, the redemption fee $500 and trading the basket costs 5 basis points.
- Buy one creation unit of the ETF$4,992,500
- Sell the basket short at the same time$5,000,000
- Redeem the ETF shares for the basketThe basket delivered closes the shortflat
- Gross profit0.15% of $5 million+$7,500
- Redemption feeFlat, per order−$500
- Cost of trading the basket5 basis points of $5 million−$2,500
Net +$4,500. In practice a market maker rarely does this so literally: it hedges with futures through the day, nets buyers against sellers, and redeems only the remainder – and it values the basket with its own real-time model, not a published figure that may be minutes old.
Where the redemption’s profit went
Pricing a basket you cannot see
The hard part of ETF market making is valuing the basket when it is not trading. A US-listed fund of Japanese shares trades all New York day while Tokyo is shut; a corporate bond fund holds bonds that may not have traded for days. The ETF is often the best live price for its own basket – and the market maker’s fair-value model has to say what the basket would be worth if it traded now.
Worked example
A Japan ETF while Tokyo is closed
The fund’s published net asset value, struck at Tokyo’s close, is $70.00. Since then Nikkei futures have risen 1.5% and the dollar has risen 0.5% against the yen. The ETF trades at $70.90.
- Move the basket with the futures71.05
- Convert at the new exchange rate$70.70
- Premium to the stale NAV1.29%
- Premium to fair value0.29%
The fund looks 1.3% rich against its published value but is only 0.3% rich against what the basket is worth now. Most of the apparent premium is a stale price – which is exactly the situation in March 2020 and on 24 August 2015.
An ETF’s price against the value of its holdings
Risk and what goes wrong
- Stale baskets: the ETF reprices instantly while its holdings, or the index built from them, use old prices.
- Hedge mismatch: futures and related funds hedge the basket only approximately, and the difference can widen when it matters most.
- Balance sheet: closing a large discount means buying and holding ETF shares and selling bonds, which dealers may be unable or unwilling to do in a crisis.
- Operational: thousands of baskets, corporate actions and currencies, each a chance to misprice.
A loss hidden on an ETF desk · September 2011
A trader on a large bank’s ETF and synthetic equities desk in London booked fictitious hedges against exposure that reached $12 billion against limits of $100 million. The bank lost $2.3 billion; the trader was jailed for seven years.
The open that could not price · 24 August 2015
The S&P 500 ETF opened 5.2% down and fell 7.8% by 9:35, while the published index – still using Friday’s prices for stocks that had not opened – showed far less. There were 1,278 trading pauses, 1,058 of them in exchange-traded products, and 20 of the 50 largest fell 10% or more at some point.
Bond ETFs below their stated value · March 2020
A large investment-grade bond ETF closed 5.0% below its net asset value on 12 March, against never more than 1% in 2018–19. The bonds behind the value had barely traded; the issuer argued the ETF price, not the stale value, was the real one. The gap closed when the Federal Reserve announced it would buy corporate bonds and bond ETFs.
Average gap between price and value, before and during March 2020
| Fund | January–February | March–April |
|---|---|---|
| Investment-grade bond ETF (LQD) | 0.13% | 1.39% |
| High-yield bond ETF (HYG) | 0.21% | 1.06% |
| Long Treasury ETF (TLT) | 0.13% | 0.86% |
Technology and data
- Real-time valuation of thousands of baskets from the published holdings, live prices, exchange rates, accrued cash and dividends.
- Fair-value models for closed or illiquid baskets: futures, related ETFs and depositary receipts for shares; bond trade reports, dealer quotes and credit indices for bonds.
- Hedge optimisation: the cheapest instrument, or combination, that tracks a basket closely enough.
- Automated creation and redemption orders, with inventory netted across funds before anything is sent.
Who works here
ETF trader
Sets fair-value adjustments for closed markets before the open, then runs the quoting engine, prices large requests for quotes from institutions, chooses hedges and decides when to create or redeem. After the close, splits the day’s P&L into spread, basis and hedge slippage.
Quant researcher
Builds fair-value models for stale baskets and bonds, proxy-hedge baskets, and models of which requests for quotes to win and at what price.
Developer
Builds the basket ingestion and pricing engine, the quoting system, automated primary-market orders and the risk system.
In interviews for this desk
Expect to price a basket quickly, explain why an ETF can trade away from its value and how that closes, and play market-making games. Firms that specialise in ETFs often ask candidates to price one against its holdings.
A US-listed Japan ETF’s last NAV is $70.00. Nikkei futures are up 1.5% since Tokyo closed and the dollar is up 0.5% against the yen. What is it worth?
About . A price of $70.90 looks 1.3% rich to the published value but is only 0.3% rich to fair value.
An ETF trades at a 0.15% discount on a $5 million creation unit. Redemption costs $500 and the basket 5 basis points to trade. Do you redeem?
Gross $7,500, less $500 and $2,500, nets $4,500 – yes, if your fair value agrees the discount is real and not a stale NAV.
Why did bond ETFs trade well below their NAV in March 2020?
The NAV was built from bond prices that were stale or indicative while the ETF traded live, so much of the discount was the ETF discovering the true price. The rest was cost: redeeming means taking bonds dealers could not easily sell, with balance sheet scarce.
What is the difference between an authorised participant and a lead market maker?
An authorised participant has an agreement with the issuer to create and redeem shares, with no obligation to. A lead market maker is appointed by the exchange to quote the ETF continuously. One firm is often both.
Creations and redemptions are usually made in kind – shares for a basket of securities. Why does that matter to a US fund’s investors?
When an authorised participant redeems, the fund hands over securities instead of selling them for cash, so it does not realise capital gains – and it can hand over the holdings bought most cheaply. Gains that a mutual fund would have to distribute to all its investors stay inside the ETF, which is a large part of why ETFs are tax-efficient.
A client wants to buy $50 million of an equity ETF now. How do you price it?
Start from the basket’s live fair value, add the cost of hedging – futures, the basket itself or related ETFs – and the creation fee if you would create, plus a margin for the market moving while you hedge. Quote that; then hedge immediately and create later if it is cheaper.
Firm guides: Jane Street · Flow Traders · Optiver · Citadel Securities
Glossary
- Authorised participant
- A dealer with an agreement to create and redeem ETF shares directly with the fund.
- Lead market maker
- The exchange-appointed quoter for an ETF.
- Creation unit
- The block in which ETF shares are created or redeemed, typically 50,000 shares.
- Basket
- The securities and cash exchanged for a creation unit, published daily.
- NAV
- Net asset value: the end-of-day value of the fund’s holdings per share.
- Premium / discount
- The ETF’s price relative to its NAV.
- In kind
- Creation or redemption with securities rather than cash.
- Custom basket
- A basket that differs from the fund’s pro rata holdings, agreed under the fund’s policy.
- Fair value
- The market maker’s own estimate of what the basket is worth now.
- Primary / secondary market
- Creations and redemptions with the fund, against trading between investors on exchange.
Further reading
- The Exchange-Traded Funds Manual – Gary L. Gastineau, 2010. Second edition, Wiley
- 2026 Investment Company Fact Book, chapter 4 – Investment Company Institute, 2026
- Equity Market Volatility on August 24, 2015 – SEC Division of Trading and Markets staff, 2015
- The anatomy of bond ETF arbitrage – Karamfil Todorov, 2021
- When Selling Becomes Viral: Disruptions in Debt Markets in the COVID-19 Crisis – Valentin Haddad, Alan Moreira and Tyler Muir, 2021