Arbitrage and relative value
Commodities and energy trading
Commodities are physical: they have to be stored, shipped, refined and burned. Their prices are linked by those costs – a barrel now and a barrel in six months, gas in Texas and gas in Europe, crude and the petrol made from it – and commodity traders make money on the spreads between them, often by owning or renting the tanks, ships and power plants that connect them.
At a glance
At a glance
- Makes money from
- Spreads across time, location and quality, and the options embedded in storage, transport and plants
- Holds positions for
- Hours to months; physical cargoes take weeks to deliver
- Trades
- Futures, options and swaps on oil, gas, power, metals and crops, and the physical goods themselves
- Biggest risk
- Squeezes when physical supply runs short, storage running out, and weather
- Who does it
- Trading houses such as Vitol, Trafigura and Glencore, banks, and firms such as Citadel, DRW and Optiver
- $8–8.5bn – Vitol’s net profit (2024, as reported by Reuters)
- −$37.63 – where a WTI oil future settled (20 April 2020)
- $100k+ – nickel per tonne on the LME, briefly (8 March 2022)
- $9,000 – per MWh, the Texas power cap, held for days (February 2021)
- 3:2:1 – barrels of crude : petrol : diesel (the standard crack spread)
- ~$6bn – Amaranth’s loss on gas spreads (September 2006)
The business
A barrel of oil in Texas today, a barrel in Rotterdam next month and a barrel’s worth of diesel are three different things with three different prices. What ties them together is the cost of getting from one to another: storage, shipping and refining. When the gap between two prices is wider than that cost, a trader who controls a tank, a ship or a refinery can buy one, turn it into the other and lock in the difference.
That is the business of the big trading houses – Vitol, Trafigura, Glencore, Gunvor, Mercuria – which buy from producers, ship and blend, sell to refiners and utilities, and hedge the price risk on futures exchanges. Their profits rose to records in 2022, when war and sanctions disrupted energy flows and widened every spread. Alongside them, banks make markets in commodity derivatives for producers and airlines, and hedge funds and trading firms trade the futures and options, increasingly with their own physical arms.
How a physical trader connects a market
The shape of the futures curve says what the market is paying for storage. In contango, later delivery costs more, and it pays to buy now and store. In backwardation, the commodity is scarce now and later delivery is cheaper: holders earn a convenience yield from having it on hand.
Two shapes of the futures curve
A trade, step by step
Worked example
Cash and carry in crude oil
Spot crude is $70.00 a barrel and the six-month future $75.45. Storage costs $0.40 a barrel a month and money costs 5% a year. Insurance and losses in the tank are left out.
- Buy now, sell six months forward$5.45
- Storage−$2.40
- Financing the barrel−$1.75
- Locked in, per barrel$1.30
- On a 2-million-barrel cargo$2.6m
No view on the oil price is needed – the future is sold on day one. The profit belongs to whoever has the tank: when storage is scarce its rent rises until the trade no longer pays, which is how the curve and storage costs stay in line. In 2020, with onshore tanks full, traders stored oil on supertankers at sea.
The carry trade, per barrel
The maths that matters
Cost of carry. A storable commodity’s future is pinned to spot by the cost of holding it: , where is the interest rate, the storage cost and the convenience yield, all as annual rates. When stocks are high, is small and the curve is in contango; when they are low, is large and the curve backwardates. Power cannot be stored at scale, so its forward prices need not line up at all.
Spreads. Most commodity trading is a spread: one month against another (calendar), one place against another (location), or an input against its outputs. A refinery’s margin is the crack spread; a gas power plant’s is the spark spread.
Worked example
A refinery’s 3:2:1 crack spread
Three barrels of crude make roughly two of petrol and one of diesel. Crude is $70 a barrel; petrol $2.30 and diesel $2.50 a gallon, with 42 gallons to the barrel.
- Petrol per barrel$96.60
- Diesel per barrel$105.00
- Products from 3 barrels$298.20
- Less 3 barrels of crude$88.20
- Per barrel of crude$29.40
If running the refinery costs less than about $29 a barrel, it pays to run it. A refiner locks in the margin by buying crude futures and selling petrol and diesel futures – trading the crack spread – and a trader who owns refining capacity owns a call option on it.
Worked example
A gas plant’s spark spread
Power sells for $60 a megawatt-hour, gas costs $3.00 per million British thermal units (MMBtu), and the plant needs 7 MMBtu of gas for each MWh – its heat rate.
- Fuel cost per MWh$21
- Spark spread$39 per MWh
The plant runs in any hour when the spark spread covers its other running costs, and stays off otherwise. That makes it a string of call options, one for every hour, on the spark spread – and that is how traders value power plants and price contracts to buy their output. In Europe the cost of carbon permits is subtracted too, giving the clean spark spread.
Seasonality. Demand for gas peaks in winter and for power in heat waves, so forward curves have a seasonal shape that storage smooths but cannot remove. Calendar spreads between summer and winter – what a gas storage facility earns by filling in summer and emptying in winter – are among the most traded.
The seasonal gas curve
Where the money comes from
Physical assets are options on spreads
| Asset | Turns | Into | The option on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Storage tank or gas cavern | Commodity now | Commodity later | The calendar spread |
| Ship or pipeline capacity | Here | There | The location spread |
| Refinery | Crude | Petrol and diesel | The crack spread |
| Gas power plant | Gas | Electricity | The spark spread |
| Blending facility | Lower grades | A specified grade | The quality spread |
- Physical trading: the spreads above, earned by moving and transforming goods, with the price risk hedged.
- Information: a physical trader sees cargoes, refinery outages and inventories before they show up in official data.
- Market making: futures and options on exchanges, and swaps for producers, airlines and utilities who hedge.
- Systematic and relative-value trading: calendar and location spreads, fundamentals models of supply and demand, and trend following across commodity futures.
- Volatility: commodity options, where skews and smiles are shaped by supply shocks – often the calls, not the puts, are expensive.
Risk and what goes wrong
Commodity prices jump when physical supply fails: a pipeline shuts, a cold snap arrives, a war closes a route. Futures that settle by physical delivery can squeeze anyone who cannot make or take delivery, and spreads that look like hedges can move violently against both legs.
Metallgesellschaft · 1993
A US arm of the German group hedged long-term fixed-price oil supply contracts with short-dated futures, rolled each month. When prices fell and the curve moved into contango, the hedge needed cash immediately while the gains on the contracts would come over years; the losses were about $1.3 billion.
Amaranth · September 2006
The hedge fund lost about $6 billion in weeks on natural gas spreads, chiefly long winter against short spring, which collapsed as its positions grew too large to exit.
Oil below zero · 20 April 2020
With demand collapsing in the pandemic and the storage hub at Cushing, Oklahoma, filling up, holders of the expiring May WTI future had nowhere to put the oil. The contract settled at −$37.63 a barrel.
Winter Storm Uri · February 2021
A freeze knocked out gas supply and power plants in Texas. Wholesale power hit the $9,000-per-MWh cap and was held there by the regulator for days; several utilities and energy retailers went bankrupt.
The nickel squeeze · 8 March 2022
After Russia invaded Ukraine, nickel more than doubled in a day on the London Metal Exchange, briefly above $100,000 a tonne, against a large short held by the Chinese producer Tsingshan. The LME suspended trading and cancelled about $3.9 billion of trades; the FCA later fined it £9.2 million.
European gas · August 2022
As Russian pipeline supply was cut, the Dutch TTF gas price, Europe’s benchmark, rose above €300 per MWh – about ten times its usual level – and margin calls on hedges left European utilities needing government support.
Technology and data
- Fundamentals models: supply, demand and inventories for each market, updated as data arrives – the US government’s weekly oil and gas storage reports move prices every week.
- Weather: forecasts and ensemble models drive gas and power demand, and wind and solar supply; power desks employ meteorologists.
- Alternative data: satellite images of tanks and crops, ship-tracking signals for every tanker, and flows on pipelines and power lines.
- Power grid models that simulate which plants run each hour, and price the forward curve from them.
- Trading and risk systems that track physical cargoes, contracts and deliveries alongside futures and options.
Who works here
Trader
Runs a book in one market – crude, products, gas, power, metals – trading spreads and outright positions, and on physical desks deciding where cargoes go.
Quant analyst or strat
Builds the models that value storage, plants and transport as options, prices structured deals for producers and consumers, and builds fundamentals and weather models.
Researcher or data scientist
Turns weather, satellite, shipping and grid data into forecasts of supply, demand and prices – especially in power, where fundamentals change by the hour.
Operator or scheduler
Makes the physical side happen: nominating pipeline capacity, scheduling ships and power plants, and handling deliveries.
In interviews for this desk
Expect mental arithmetic with units – barrels, gallons, tonnes, MWh – and questions on carry, contango and backwardation, spreads and options. Physical and power desks want to see that you understand the logistics; systematic desks test statistics and coding.
Spot crude is $70, the six-month future $75.45, storage $0.40 a barrel a month and rates 5%. Is there a trade?
Buy spot, store and sell the future. Storage is , financing , so the locked-in profit is a barrel – if you have a tank.
Crude is $70 a barrel, petrol $2.30 a gallon and diesel $2.50. What is the 3:2:1 crack spread?
Petrol is a barrel and diesel 105.00. a barrel of crude.
Power is $60 per MWh, gas $3 per MMBtu and a plant’s heat rate is 7. Should it run?
The spark spread is per MWh. It should run if that covers its other running costs – and a plant with a lower heat rate earns more from the same prices.
How can an oil price be negative?
A future that settles by delivery obliges its holder at expiry to take the oil. In April 2020 storage at the delivery point was almost full, so holders of the May contract who could not take delivery paid others to take it off them, down to −$37.63 a barrel. Spot oil elsewhere stayed positive.
Spot is $80 and the one-year future $72, with rates at 5% and storage at 2% a year. What convenience yield does that imply?
From : . Holders are willing to forgo that much for having the oil now – stocks are tight.
Why is a gas storage facility like an option?
It gives the right to buy gas in one month and sell it in another, whenever the spread pays more than the cost of injecting and withdrawing. Its value is the intrinsic spread on the forward curve today plus the extra from being able to change plans as spreads move – a strip of calendar-spread options.
A calendar spread is long one month and short the next. Why can it still lose a fortune?
The two months are not the same thing: different supply and demand, and different holders. Amaranth’s long-winter, short-spring gas spread fell even as both prices fell, and its size meant it could not get out. Spreads need limits on size and liquidity, not only on outright exposure.
Glossary
- Contango
- A curve where later delivery costs more than now.
- Backwardation
- A curve where later delivery costs less than now.
- Cost of carry
- Financing plus storage, less any yield: what links spot and futures.
- Convenience yield
- The benefit of holding the physical commodity rather than a future on it.
- Crack spread
- Refined products against the crude they are made from: a refinery’s margin.
- Spark spread
- Power against the gas needed to make it: a gas plant’s margin.
- Heat rate
- How much fuel a power plant burns to make a megawatt-hour.
- Calendar spread
- One delivery month against another of the same commodity.
- Roll
- Closing an expiring future and opening a later one.
- Physical delivery
- Settling a future by handing over the commodity itself.
- Squeeze
- Prices forced up when those short cannot deliver and must buy back from those who are long.
- Cushing
- The Oklahoma storage hub where the WTI oil future is delivered.
Further reading
- The World for Sale – Javier Blas and Jack Farchy, 2021. A history of the commodity trading houses
- Commodities and Commodity Derivatives – Hélyette Geman, 2005. Wiley
- The Economics of Commodity Trading Firms – Craig Pirrong, 2014
- Weekly Petroleum Status Report – US Energy Information Administration, 2026. The data the oil market waits for every Wednesday
- Interim Staff Report: Trading in NYMEX WTI Crude Oil Futures Leading up to, on, and around April 20, 2020 – Commodity Futures Trading Commission, 2020