Systematic investing
Systematic macro and trend following
Systematic macro funds trade futures and forwards on stock indices, government bonds, currencies and commodities by rule. The best-known style is trend following: go long what has been rising and short what has been falling, sized so each market contributes similar risk. Funds that do this are often called CTAs, after the US registration as a commodity trading advisor, or managed futures.
At a glance
At a glance
- Makes money from
- Persistent trends across many markets; often strong in long sell-offs
- Holds positions for
- Weeks to months
- Trades
- Liquid futures and forwards across equities, bonds, currencies and commodities
- Biggest risk
- Choppy, trendless markets with repeated whipsaws, and long flat periods
- Who does it
- Managers such as Man AHL, Winton and Aspect Capital, and managed-futures funds at firms such as AQR
- ~$365bn – managed by CTAs (BarclayHedge, end of 2025)
- +13.9% – Barclay CTA Index in 2008 (as world shares fell about 40%)
- +27.4% – SG Trend Index in 2022 (its best year since 2000)
- 8 of 10 – worst 60/40 drawdowns in which trend made money (Hurst, Ooi and Pedersen)
- −4.9% – SG Trend Index in April 2025 (the tariff whipsaw)
- −20.4% – index drawdown, May 2024 to May 2025 (SG Trend)
The business
Trend following is one of the oldest systematic strategies. Richard Donchian ran a public futures fund on trend rules from 1949; in 1983 the traders Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt taught a group of novices – the “Turtles” – a complete rule-based system to settle a bet about whether trading could be taught. Today the industry is dominated by large firms with research teams, such as Man AHL, Winton, Aspect and the managed-futures arms of AQR and others.
It is asset management: investors pay a management fee and usually a performance fee for a return stream that is diversifying – roughly uncorrelated with stocks and bonds on average, and often positive in long sell-offs. Funds trade only liquid futures and forwards, so their capacity is large and their positions can be cut in a day.
A trend and its moving averages
The rule can be as simple as comparing two moving averages: long while the 50-day average is above the 200-day, short while it is below. Another is the sign of the past 12 months’ return – time-series momentum, which Moskowitz, Ooi and Pedersen (2012) found in all 58 futures markets they studied. Real systems blend several speeds and many markets, but the principle is the same – do not forecast, follow. Most trades lose a little; a few long trends pay for all of them.
A trade, step by step
Positions are sized by volatility, not by money: a market twice as volatile gets half the position, so a quiet bond future and a wild commodity contribute similar risk.
Worked example
Sizing a trend portfolio
A $100 million fund trades 40 markets and gives each $1 million of annual volatility. A crude oil future covers 1,000 barrels at $70 and crude’s volatility is 35% a year; a 10-year Treasury future has a notional of about $110,000 and volatility of 6%.
- Crude: risk per contract$24,500
- Crude contracts≈ 41
- Treasury contracts≈ 152
- Portfolio vol, markets independent6.3%
- At average correlation 0.114.0%
The fund holds almost four times as many bond contracts as oil contracts for the same risk. And the portfolio’s volatility depends heavily on correlation: if markets move together, as they do in a crisis, the same positions carry three times the risk, so funds re-estimate volatility daily and scale everything down when it rises.
Diversification depends on correlation
The maths that matters
Estimating volatility. Funds use an exponentially weighted average of squared returns, . Moskowitz, Ooi and Pedersen used , a centre of mass of 60 days: each day’s weight halves after about 42 days. Each position is then .
The shape of the returns. Because a trend follower ends up short a market that has fallen far and long one that has risen far, its returns against the market look like a long straddle: gains in big moves either way, small losses in quiet markets. Fung and Hsieh (2001) showed that trend-following funds behave like options that pay off on a market’s range – the reason they tend to do well in long crises and poorly in choppy markets.
Trend following behaves like a straddle
Patience is a statistic. A strategy with a Sharpe ratio of 0.5 has a five-year Sharpe ratio of , so the chance of losing money over a whole five years is about . Long lean periods are not evidence that it has stopped working – which makes it very hard to tell when it actually has.
Rolling. Futures expire, so positions are rolled into the next contract. In a backwardated market (later contracts cheaper) a long position earns as each contract rises towards spot; in contango it pays. This roll yield is a large part of commodity returns and is itself a signal – the carry strategies that many trend followers run alongside trend.
Where the money comes from
A good year for a trend fund
Trend following’s record, by year
| Period | Return | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| 2008 | +13.9%, Barclay CTA Index | Long bonds and short shares and commodities through the crisis |
| 2009–2013 | Lean | Choppy, policy-driven markets with few lasting trends |
| 2014 | A double-digit gain | Oil halved; bonds rallied; the dollar rose |
| 2022 | +27.4%, SG Trend Index | Short bonds and long commodities as inflation and rates rose |
| May 2024 – May 2025 | −20.4% peak to trough, SG Trend Index | Reversals, ending with the April 2025 tariff shock |
- Trend: the core – many speeds, many markets.
- Carry: earn the difference between spot and futures prices, such as the interest differential between currencies or commodity roll yield.
- Macro signals: rules built on economic data, valuations or central-bank policy.
- Risk parity: a related systematic style that holds bonds, shares and commodities in proportions that equalise their risk.
Risk and what goes wrong
Trend followers lose in sharp reversals – a trend that ends suddenly, before the signals turn – and in markets that chop sideways. Their positions are liquid, but similar across funds, so many funds cut the same positions at once in a reversal. Hurst, Ooi and Pedersen found trend following made money in 8 of the 10 worst drawdowns for a 60/40 portfolio since 1880; the exceptions, and the long flat spells in between, are when investors give up.
The first trend fund · 1949
Richard Donchian launches Futures Inc., a public commodity fund run on trend rules – the moving-average and breakout ideas still in use.
The Turtles · 1983
Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt train a group of novices in a complete breakout system. Several go on to run their own funds, and the rules are later published.
Crisis alpha · 2008
As shares fell about 40%, trend followers were short equities and commodities and long bonds; the Barclay CTA Index of managed-futures funds gained 13.9%, its best year since 1990; every CTA in Société Générale’s database made money, and many made more than 30%. Assets flooded in.
Five lean years · 2009–2013
Markets driven by central-bank interventions reversed often. Returns were thin for five years, and many investors left.
Bonds and shares fall together · 2022
With inflation surging, bonds and shares fell at the same time – the worst year for a 60/40 portfolio in decades. Trend followers, short bonds and long commodities, had one of their best years.
The tariff whipsaw · April 2025
The US tariff announcements reversed trends across markets within days; the SG Trend Index lost 4.9% in the month, the low point of a drawdown of about 20% from May 2024.
Technology and data
- Clean, continuous futures price histories, stitched across contract rolls, going back decades – some firms have reconstructed data back to the 1800s.
- Volatility and correlation estimates updated daily, feeding position sizes and portfolio risk targets.
- Execution across hundreds of futures markets, timed around rolls and liquidity, often through algorithms that trade over the day.
- Research tools to test new signals and markets without overfitting – the history of most markets is only a few decades long.
Who works here
Quant researcher
Researches signals – trend, carry, macro – and portfolio construction, and adds new markets. Most of the work is careful statistics on short, noisy histories.
Portfolio manager
Oversees the systematic programme, sets risk targets, and explains drawdowns to investors who are often nervous.
Execution trader
Manages how the system’s orders reach the market across hundreds of futures, and the timing of rolls.
Quant developer
Builds the data pipelines, the research platform and the production system that runs the strategy every day.
In interviews for this desk
Expect time series and statistics, how backtests mislead (look-ahead, survivorship, overfitting), the Sharpe ratio and drawdowns, and how futures work – including rolling from one contract to the next.
You want $1m of annual volatility in crude oil. A contract is 1,000 barrels at $70 and crude’s volatility is 35%. How many contracts?
Each contract carries of annual volatility, so contracts.
Forty markets each have 1% volatility. What is the portfolio’s volatility if they are uncorrelated, and if the average correlation is 0.1?
uncorrelated; at 0.1. Even small correlations dominate when there are many positions.
Why does trend following tend to do well in crises?
Long crises are trends: shares fall for months while bonds rally, so the rules end up short shares and long bonds. Its returns against the market resemble a long straddle. Sudden one-day crashes, such as October 1987, are harder: the signals have not yet turned.
A strategy has a Sharpe ratio of 0.5. How likely is it to lose money over five years?
Its five-year Sharpe ratio is , so the probability of a loss is about – roughly one five-year window in eight, assuming normal, independent returns.
You estimate volatility with an exponential average with . How quickly does an old return’s weight halve?
days. Its centre of mass is days.
What is roll yield, and when is it positive for a long position?
The gain or loss from rolling an expiring future into the next one. In backwardation the next contract is cheaper, and it rises towards spot as it nears expiry, so a long position earns; in contango it loses. It is why holding long commodity futures has cost money when curves were in contango.
Your trend system has lost money for two years. How would you decide whether it is broken?
Compare the drawdown to what its own history and Sharpe ratio imply – two flat years are normal for a Sharpe of 0.5. Check whether markets trended and it missed them, or simply did not trend; check for changes in costs, correlations or implementation. Deciding the rule for abandoning it in advance avoids deciding at the worst moment.
Firm guides: AQR
Glossary
- CTA
- Commodity trading advisor: the US registration most trend followers hold.
- Managed futures
- Funds that trade futures systematically, mostly by trend.
- Time-series momentum
- Trading a market in the direction of its own past return.
- Moving-average crossover
- A signal from a fast average of prices crossing a slow one.
- Breakout
- A signal when price exceeds its range over a past window.
- Volatility targeting
- Scaling positions so risk stays constant as volatility changes.
- Whipsaw
- A signal flipping back and forth in a trendless market, losing each time.
- Roll yield
- The return from rolling futures along the curve.
- Carry
- What a position earns if prices do not change.
- Drawdown
- The fall from a peak to the following low.
- Crisis alpha
- Gains in long market sell-offs, the reason many investors hold trend.
Further reading
- Time Series Momentum – Tobias Moskowitz, Yao Hua Ooi and Lasse Heje Pedersen, 2012. Journal of Financial Economics
- A Century of Evidence on Trend-Following Investing – Brian Hurst, Yao Hua Ooi and Lasse Heje Pedersen, 2017. Journal of Portfolio Management
- Risk in Hedge Fund Strategies: Theory and Evidence from Trend Followers – William Fung and David Hsieh, 2001. Review of Financial Studies
- Systematic Trading – Robert Carver, 2015. A practitioner’s guide to building a futures system
- Efficiently Inefficient – Lasse Heje Pedersen, 2015. Chapters on managed futures and global macro