Numerical pricing: Monte Carlo, finite differences and when to use which
PRC · Chapter 413 min readAsked at Optiver, SIG, Akuna, Citadel Securities
Assumes Binomial trees, backward induction and early exercise.
1:05The lesson in a minutePremium
The key idea, drawn and talked through in a short video before you read. Lesson videos come with Premium.
Start the 7-day free trialUnlockAfter this lesson you should be able to
- Choose between a lattice, a PDE solver and Monte Carlo from the payoff.
- State the error rate of each and what improves it.
- Explain how Longstaff–Schwartz handles early exercise in a simulation.
Three families of numerical method cover almost everything: lattices, finite-difference PDE solvers and Monte Carlo. The choice is not a matter of taste – it falls out of two features of the payoff, whether it is path-dependent and how many underlyings it has.
| Method | Error | Strong at | Fails at |
|---|---|---|---|
| Binomial lattice | , oscillating | One asset, early exercise | Path dependence, several assets |
| Finite differences | One or two assets, Greeks for free | Dimension beyond about three | |
| Monte Carlo | Path dependence, many assets | Early exercise, and Greeks |
Why dimension decides it. A grid method needs points in every dimension, so its cost grows like – twenty points per axis is fine in one dimension and hopeless in five. Monte Carlo’s error is regardless of dimension, because it is estimating an average and the central limit theorem does not care how many variables went into each draw. So the crossover is sharp: below about three dimensions grids win comfortably, above it they cannot be built at all.
Proposition 4.3
Monte Carlo for options
Simulate the underlying under the risk-neutral measure, evaluate the payoff on each path, average, and discount. Use the exact lognormal step rather than an Euler discretisation when you can – for geometric Brownian motion the solution is known, so there is no need to introduce a discretisation error.
Holds when
- Exact step: .
- For a path-independent payoff, simulate straight to expiry in one step.
- Antithetic variates are free and typically worth a factor of two; a control variate using the vanilla with a known Black–Scholes price is usually worth much more.
Example 4.4
Sizing a simulation
A Monte Carlo price has a payoff standard deviation of $20. How many paths for a standard error of one cent?
Show the worked solutionHide the worked solution
Worked solution
- Formula
- Substitute
- Solve
- Answer
Sanity check. And one more decimal place would cost four hundred million. That arithmetic is why variance reduction is not an optimisation but a necessity – halving saves three quarters of the work.
The rest of this lesson is in Premium
You have read the opening. 12 more sections follow, including 4 worked examples and 3 quick checks.
Nothing is charged for 7 days, and you can cancel before then. Not ready for a trial? A free account, with no card, saves your progress and opens the free questions, the drills and a mock paper. Or read Forwards, futures and the cost of carry in full, free.