Games, decision theory and puzzles
You roll a fair die and may re-roll once, keeping the second value if you do.
You roll a fair die and may re-roll once, keeping the second value if you do. What is the game worth?
Answer with a number. Fractions, powers and expressions like 23/6 or C(52,5) are read correctly in practice.
Try it
Next free question: You are flat and showing 99 at 101.
Show the answer and worked solution
Answer
Work backwards from the second roll. Re-rolling hands you a fresh die worth 3.5, so the only decision on the first roll is whether the face beats 3.5: keep 4, 5 and 6, re-roll 1, 2 and 3. That turns the game into the average of over the six faces, . The usual slip is to re-roll a 4 because it is below the value of the game; the comparison is against the continuation value of 3.5, not against 4.25.
Worked solution
- Formula
- Substitute
- Solve
- Answer
Takeaway: The threshold is the continuation value, not the mean of the distribution.
Report an issue with this question
Learn the method
Of the kind reported at
More games, decision theory and puzzles questions
- You may re-roll a fair die as often as you like, free of charge, and are paid…Advanced · Free solution
- Hiring the best candidate, part 3 of 3Advanced · Premium
- A shuffled deck of 26 red and 26 black cards is turned over one card at a time.Expert · Premium
- Two players take turns flipping a fair coin, and the first to flip heads wins.Foundation · Premium
- A die game with paid re-rolls, part 1 of 3Foundation · Premium
- Hiring the best candidate, part 1 of 3Foundation · Premium