Market making
You are flat and showing 99 at 101.
You are flat and showing 99 at 101. You get lifted three times in a row and are now substantially short. What should your next market look like?
- AWider, still centred on 100
- BHigher, and the same width
- CSame bid, higher ask
- DUnchanged – three fills is noise
Try it
Pick an answer
Next free question: An index rises 10% then falls 10%.
Show the answer and worked solution
Answer: B – Higher, and the same width
Separate the two decisions. Width answers how sure you are of your value, and three fills have told you nothing about your precision, so the width should not change. Skew answers what you are holding and what the flow is saying, and here both point the same way: you are short and need to buy back, and repeated lifts suggest the true value is above where you were quoting. So move the whole market up and keep it the same width. Widening after a fill is the common reflex and it is the wrong lever; leaving the bid where it was leaves you buying at a price you no longer want.
- A. Widening implies you have become less sure, which is not what a fill tells you.
- B. Correct. Both fills and inventory point up; your uncertainty is unchanged, so the width should be too.
- C. That widens rather than moves, and it leaves you bidding where you no longer want to buy.
- D. Repeated fills on one side are the clearest information you will get, and ignoring them is the most visible error in this round.
Takeaway: Width answers "how sure am I"; skew answers "what am I holding". Never let one do the other’s job.
Report an issue with this question
Learn the method
Of the kind reported at
More market making questions
- You are asked to make a market on the sum of two fair six-sided dice.Foundation · Free solution
- Make a ninety per cent market on the sum of ten fair dice.Applied · Premium
- What is your theoretical value for the maximum of three fair six-sided dice, to…Applied · Premium
- You make a 95% market on the number of heads in 100 fair coin flips.Applied · Premium
- Make a market on the number of different faces that show when three fair dice are rolled.Applied · Premium
- Two cards are dealt from a standard deck, with ace = 1 up to king = 13.Advanced · Premium