Estimation: decompose, bound, and defend the number
FLU · Chapter 212 min readAsked at Optiver, SIG, IMC, Jane Street
Assumes Arithmetic that survives a clock.
The lesson in a minute
The key idea, drawn and talked through, before you read. Captions are on, so it works with the sound off.
Read the transcript
How many petrol stations are there in the United States? No looking it up. Talk it through out loud. Pause and try it. Most people blurt a number. About a hundred thousand? Even if it's close, it scores nothing. There's nothing to check. Build it from things you know. There are about two hundred and fifty million cars. Each one needs about forty fill-ups a year. That's ten billion fill-ups a year. Now take a single station. Say eight pumps, twenty fills each a day, three hundred and fifty days a year. That's fifty-six thousand fill-ups. Divide, and you get about a hundred and eighty thousand stations. The published figure is about a hundred and forty-five thousand. Off by a quarter, well inside a factor of two. So quote a range: eighty thousand to three hundred and fifty thousand. And name your weakest guess: pumps per station. Now the interviewer says, isn't it more like ten thousand? Don't fold. Test it. That's twenty-five thousand cars for every station. That seems far too many. Say the structure first, then the numbers, then a range. The full lesson is right below.
After this lesson you should be able to
- Decompose an unknown quantity into factors you can each estimate.
- Give an interval rather than a point, and choose its width deliberately.
- Defend an estimate under challenge without abandoning it.
Estimation questions are not testing arithmetic. They are testing whether you can build a structure out of things you do know, say how confident you are in each piece, and then hold your ground when someone pushes back. The number matters far less than the decomposition.
Proposition 2.1
The method
Break the quantity into a product of factors, estimate each one separately, multiply, then sanity-check the order of magnitude against something you know independently. Errors in the factors are partly independent, so they partly cancel rather than all compounding in one direction – which is why a four-factor decomposition is usually more accurate than a single guess at the answer.
Holds when
- Prefer factors you can anchor: populations, areas, times, rates. Avoid factors that are themselves the mystery.
- State each factor aloud as you pick it, so the interviewer can redirect you before the arithmetic.
- Round aggressively. Two significant figures is generous for a Fermi estimate.
| Quantity | Rough value |
|---|---|
| World population | 8 billion |
| United States population | 340 million |
| United Kingdom population | 68 million |
| Seconds in a year | |
| Minutes in a day | 1,440 |
| US GDP | $29 trillion |
| S&P 500 market capitalisation | roughly $50 trillion |
| Trading days in a year | 252 |
Example 2.3
How many petrol stations are there in the United States?
Show the worked solutionHide the worked solution
Worked solution
- Formula
- Substitute
- Solve
- Answer
Sanity check. The published figure is around 145,000, so this is high by about a quarter – well inside the factor of two a Fermi estimate aims for. The pumps-per-station figure is the weakest link, and saying so is part of the answer.
Estimate it twice. The strongest thing you can do with a Fermi estimate is reach the same number a second way. Here, the United States has about 340 million people and roughly 20,000 towns and cities; two or three stations per few thousand people lands in the same six-figure range. When two independent decompositions agree you have genuine evidence; when they disagree by a factor of ten you have found the factor you got wrong, which is more useful than either answer.
Proposition 2.4
Quote an interval, and pick its width
A point estimate invites the question "how sure are you?", so answer it first. A Fermi decomposition with four factors each good to a factor of two gives an answer good to roughly a factor of three or four – not sixteen, because the errors are partly independent. Say something like "about 180,000, and I would be surprised outside 80,000 to 350,000".
Holds when
- Width follows from the weakest factor, so name it: "the pumps-per-station number is the one I am least sure of".
- At a trading firm the interval is the answer – it is a market on your own estimate, and quoting it absurdly wide defeats the purpose.
The rest of this lesson is in Premium
You have read the opening. 12 more sections follow, including 5 worked examples and 3 quick checks.
Nothing is charged for 7 days, and you can cancel before then. Not ready for a trial? A free account, with no card, saves your progress and opens the free questions, the drills and a mock paper. Or read Arithmetic that survives a clock in full, free.